situation of player deaths
Moderator: Gamemasters
situation of player deaths
Now im a big supporter that you should lose some skill when you die, but what happens when you are constantly killed. It must be very dissappoting that you spend months training your character to only have him knocked back down to weak character within a weeks time. Characters that play nonfighter suffer from this too, maybe even worse.
Blacksmithing take a lot of time with berely any skill gain. I was at once was going to try and make him a purely craftperson, but with the pently system it is impossible. He did not go out looking for troble, and more often ran from his share of fights.
Within the past 3 weeks though he has remined at the same skill level. Spend over 1000 sheets of metal only to have same level. The time spent to gain this amount of ore and smithed into sheets is well over 9 hours. The only reason he wasnt able to advance though is due to the fact he was gosted 3 times.
one being killed by another player with a good RP reason. Two of them though were in one day by an npc wolf that was place in the town. Now death is a bad thing, but sometimes it cannot be avoided. The skill lost doesnt really help RP. It just allows for powerful players to knock down anyone that might become a threat to them.
Now to the main point of me writting is this is that there should be a skill lost but over time you should gain back 30 percent of your skill lost. This is for the healing of the character. Or perhaps over time all the skill should be gained back, but if the character keeps getting killed the lost should be perment. The time for the skill to come back should be IG time so that the player just doent log in to stay out of danger of perment skill lost.
This way an "assanation" of power characters can be done to knock their power down so that way so they are not a threat any more.
What do yall think about this idea?
Blacksmithing take a lot of time with berely any skill gain. I was at once was going to try and make him a purely craftperson, but with the pently system it is impossible. He did not go out looking for troble, and more often ran from his share of fights.
Within the past 3 weeks though he has remined at the same skill level. Spend over 1000 sheets of metal only to have same level. The time spent to gain this amount of ore and smithed into sheets is well over 9 hours. The only reason he wasnt able to advance though is due to the fact he was gosted 3 times.
one being killed by another player with a good RP reason. Two of them though were in one day by an npc wolf that was place in the town. Now death is a bad thing, but sometimes it cannot be avoided. The skill lost doesnt really help RP. It just allows for powerful players to knock down anyone that might become a threat to them.
Now to the main point of me writting is this is that there should be a skill lost but over time you should gain back 30 percent of your skill lost. This is for the healing of the character. Or perhaps over time all the skill should be gained back, but if the character keeps getting killed the lost should be perment. The time for the skill to come back should be IG time so that the player just doent log in to stay out of danger of perment skill lost.
This way an "assanation" of power characters can be done to knock their power down so that way so they are not a threat any more.
What do yall think about this idea?
Well, for the part where you tell its hardly possible to have a character without fighting and danger, you are right. Currently, with the temple having TONS of members, including pushed ones and bandits, agaisnt an absent town guard and a knighthood which is currently weak, the town is not safe. Also that the members of the temple are the one attacking, so it is much easier, they can get in group and attack a moment where there are not many defenders in the town, and bingo, raid successful. Maybe when this quest finishes (if it does), Trollsbane can have a town guard (which is pretty impossible right now since they get killed by temple members), and then characters that do not want to have part in conflicts will be able to, just wanted to point that out.
- Skaalib Drurr
- Posts: 1007
- Joined: Sat Aug 05, 2006 11:30 pm
- Location: A place which I call home......
- Richard Cypher
- Posts: 687
- Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2006 11:48 pm
- Location: U.S. of America, Massachusetts
- WickedEwok
- Posts: 267
- Joined: Mon Aug 28, 2006 5:10 pm
I don't think that we should set a different loss.Thurbert~ wrote:Or just limit skill loss to fighting and magery skills and make the non-combat skills unaffected.
Death etc depends on your playing style. If you are a trader/craftsman, you shouldn't walk around without any protection and if you do, you should be very careful. If you can't fight and provoke others, you should have fighters around you all the time.
I also think that it's very hard for a fighter to lose his equipment on death, a craftsman still got his skill to craft another/make money fast - but a fighter without equipment is nothing. Mages... well, mages are another category.
The system now works pretty fine for me.
- Skaalib Drurr
- Posts: 1007
- Joined: Sat Aug 05, 2006 11:30 pm
- Location: A place which I call home......
The effects of death were discussed many times, e.g. here, here, here and here.
At the moment I think dying is quite dangerous because it takes a lot of skill and with the actual system it's not very easy to get back to your pre-death level.
The positive thing is that killings happen not so often anymore, but on the other hand are there some situation where a fight should happen but the participants seem not to risk one because of skill-loss... (Or they will push a fight when someone is sure to win)
So, I would lower the negative effect a bit, maye just reset the internal experience for some skills and not reduce gained levels.
At the moment I think dying is quite dangerous because it takes a lot of skill and with the actual system it's not very easy to get back to your pre-death level.
The positive thing is that killings happen not so often anymore, but on the other hand are there some situation where a fight should happen but the participants seem not to risk one because of skill-loss... (Or they will push a fight when someone is sure to win)
So, I would lower the negative effect a bit, maye just reset the internal experience for some skills and not reduce gained levels.
- Kevin Lightdot
- Posts: 2849
- Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2005 8:17 pm
- Location: Green again
- Kevin Lightdot
- Posts: 2849
- Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2005 8:17 pm
- Location: Green again
Uhm, I have three bright green skills, a few teal, a few light blue and a few dark blue.Solumn wrote:It depends on your skill level. To certain point, you wil lose no further.Kevin Lightdot wrote:Uhm, I'm to tired to read all this right now but last time I died(Yesterday)... I don't think I lost any skill.
I don't think I lost anything, for as far as I can see by the colours.
- Samantha Meryadeles
- Posts: 1879
- Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2005 2:48 pm
- Contact:
Item loss wasn't always though, used to be you died you lost nothing, now you will loose everything if the cross isn't more than 30 seconds away.Nalzaxx wrote:Skill loss has always been heavily debated and contested. Yet it has always been with us. I think we should wait untill the problems are ironed out before we suggest any changes.