The role of captain of the guard has been polotical one since pendars arrival on the island. As such what ever force the guard may hold becomes a point of political leverage. As would have been the case if the our friends in the north handnt agreed to hand back the desert for fair compensation

In reality though we are not in Illarion fighting over seas the island is small and what ever the threat is sits right on your door step. I cant imagine a miedeval malitia "what the guard really is". Not stepping up to answers threats to there town.
Also we should propably be honest and say for the months I have been playing the guard has not numbered over 5 active players. Usually around 3, Currently I suppose the guard contains 3-4 skilled warriors. Were as it may be strange that they run out and leave the town abandoned I doubt the possibly 3 logged in really make that much difference to a war occurance or outcome.
Last but not least, guards like all warriors in Illarion fight at any chance they get because it is what they do lol. It is a core reality people play this game to be ammused, much as people will change there rp inside out to partake in quest. So people with fighting skills will always look for ways to use them.
Its the nature of the beast
Brian