Illarion.org

This topic is to show who's rp you did not like, I don't think it will go as well as 'Who's RP did you like today' but, it will show better what is wrong with one's roleplaying. It might turn into a flame war, but try not to make it like that.

State the person who's rp you disliked with a reason why.

( Got this idea from Who's RP did you like today, if you hadn't already guessed. )

This isn't nice.

I DIDNT LIKE NARMIR'S


Nah, I haven't seen Isilwen even

I don't agree with this topic as well. It will only end up in a flame war.

Baaaaaad plan.

Tsk tsk

Oh dear, well, you know... ITs not meant to be a really harsh 'I do not like your rp'

For example: I think ** rp could use some more work because he/she **...
Let us just go on topic and see,

No. This isn't a nice thread at all and I'm sure the GMs won't like it either. It's nasty to the other players and I'm not going to touch it with a 60 foot barge pole. Maybe a 61, but NEVER a 60. Hmph. I think I've expressed by 60 foot barge pole's worth of views here.

The learning from misstakes intension is good, but i fear, this will really end in a flame war.

Nitram

William Elderberry with his new time phrases

"Screw you"

Jon Childs wrote:William Elderberry with his new time phrases

"Screw you"

(This is one of the reasons I'm not going to touch this with a 60 foot barge pole. Jon Childs there's a lot of things I could say about you but I'm not starting any flame wars mmkay?)

Ullyatth Leader wrote:

Jon Childs wrote:William Elderberry with his new time phrases

"Screw you"

(This is one of the reasons I'm not going to touch this with a 60 foot barge pole. Jon Childs there's a lot of things I could say about you but I'm not starting any flame wars mmkay?)

And where under not touching with a 60 foot barge pole does actually posting a reply come under then?

I think generally, everyone's RP could be improved by being a little more medieval in their knowledge about the world. It always surprises me (and my characters) when someone ingame starts talking about 20th century medical knowledge in the medieval fantasy setting.

Everyone knows disease is caused by the Gods and not "Little invisible things called Germs"

Well posted Nalzaxx, a good example.

I like to call them "The invisible little biting demons".

Your so cute when you're being moderatorish. I just want to keep you and squeeze your widdle cheeks!

I DO NOT LIKE RETLAK'S RP. He is the worst player i have ever encountered i must admit, i hope he rots away.

Retlak wrote:I DO NOT LIKE RETLAK'S RP. He is the worst player i have ever encountered i must admit, i hope he rots away.

I agree

Edit: Just joking Retty...

i didnt like the lizard that LOGGED when i was chasing him

I didn't like nobody's rp, cause i was only online for about 10 minuites since the server got updated. Then i just carried on rp on msn instead of wating for the server to thaw.

@Quin.. thats what i call moderation... but anyway.. why don't you delete him directly.. i think tips to get better for the individual RP should be told personaly (over msn for example).. The 'rp like today, can make you famous for good rp.. but who wants to be famous for bad RP.. maybe they won't flame each other.. but it definitlywould take a not nice influence on the Player s reputation..
Example:

A n00b gets bad critic for his RP.. the other players are reading it..
if they are meeting him IG, they will renember that critic, and some of them maybe won't like to play with him.. just the typical trading #i and done..
of course the n00b can learn by that, and it can help him to develope his RP skills.. the other players should know that.. but not every player thinks that far..
you know i am sayin'?

Can someone close this thread please?

If you want someone to play better, talk to him personally, show him his mistakes, let him learn. But don't blame him here in the public. That isn't very useful. And its frusttrating.

Cassandra i agree with you 100 % !!!!

This Thread is the worst idea in this forum appears.

If it removes-----or closed - Please

Fair enough, be your cautious self, too afraid to say someone's rp is bad.

Here no -

my dear - this is a thing of the respect and not the afraid of speech.

We have to clear here PN around something like that, we must not blaming a Player

It is not considered blaming to criticise a player of bad rp.

It is. As Cassandra said, you could send the PO a PM, if you really want to tell him, what he could make better for the next time.

Fine, fine... I wouldn't consider it blaming, but rude.
Well then, I guess it will be locked then, for being not on topic and for the topic itself.

damn.. did anybody actualy read what i wrtoe.. if not do it gildon, it explains exactly what is wrong with your topic.. i don't say its the badest idea.. but i at least its not a very good idea.. interesting, no doubt, but not good for our flame-war-loving-community.. and not for the courage of new players..

I think this thread is a good idea....Its not really insulting...Its telling people there error.....And as Nitram said.