In fact, that was kinda shortly after when illarion became a bit more popular due to longer maintenance- and server-moving- unavailability on Tibia and after the breakdown of Era online 1. The stuff "really old" players liked was what we did before most of those "immigration waves", which all had positive as well as negative impacts on the community. Mass-PKers like Darkwalker etc. always pissed some people off, even though most PKers i encountered were definitely able to RP, when were in the mood for it - most of those that behaved really "ban-able" badly all the time were kids.
The Illarion "enforcement" history is a tale of change and reaction to change. Rules and enforcements were always done as a reaction to negative changes in the habit of a few or some of its players. Times felt always "better" before another rule became necessary, but that was only because the active people acted more friendly towards each another: even if using a rougher or more childish tone, there was somewhat less bitterness and much less childish intrigues and mean backtalk, and even if progress was extremely slow back then the staff always talked and voted about all type of matters in a majority-ruled way.
The main thing that older players nowadays miss in illarion is the more family-ish atmosphere that the community had back then. We still have a good bunch of that atmosphere at the illarion RL meetings, where many of those "olbies" that do not play anymore since ages still show up from time to time, except for those who have kids now.
To me, most of those that do, and some of those who don't, are known as "friends".
And if old-time-illarion as well as now-time-illarion do have one big thing in common, it is making friends all around the world, and learning the fact that people are people, no matter where on the world we are. The one big lesson we can learn from illarion besides that is that somehow, all we people can somehow get along, if we're just a little respectful and somewhat tolerant, as well as no too greedy or needy
*ilarionificates silly manowar text while banging wild*
Here our players come from all around the world
Waiting in the lag to see the server die
All are logged-in here the event it is there
The lich will kick the ball, bring action to us all
We alone are gaming for pwnage that is true
We own the night to play and fight we're here with all of you
Now swear the cofee-cup's inside will never dry
Stand and play together beneath digital sky
Brothers Everywhere
Toss your mice into the air
We're playriors
Playriors of The iIlla
Like noobs who log and die
Sworn to lag and cry
We're playriors
Playriors of The iIlla...