No. Perhaps you are prone to kidding, the town guard is not. Not towards such persons.So what if shes trying to be defiant. Just let her be, and she will eventualy stop.
-Tari was treated more than fairly, almost dumb, as she was about to kill anyone in sight. We showed her more mercy than a mad murderer ususally would get in any country, you might think of, while she was stabbing at us.
-Tari was not beheaded, not harmed in any way, but put into prison for this.
-Tari was released. (And, in our grace, NOT banned permanently, as we could have done with a obviously mad person)
-Tari starts to make a scene in order to show, she can resist the guard´s words.
-Even after she was made to head to the guard´s words, she came back and started to insult the guardsmen again. Would a helpless victim come back and risk to be lectured another time by force, if she didn´t want to make a scene? Don´t make me laugh.
So what? She already proved, you cannot reach her with reasoning. She tried how far she can go. And i do NOT intend to let would-be-murderers play this stupid game with the guardsmen. She tried to kill anyone in sight a few days before and should be most thankful, that we do not simply put her on a stake for her mad actions. Mocking the guardsmen, misbehaving and trying to make a scene, a few days after her killing spree, is not the most clever actions someone who really wants nothing but to live a peaceful life, without harming or insulting anyone, could do. So she is either dumb or she wanted to make a scene in order to reach such simple minded persons, who like to argue over things, they have no idea of.
But for you, Nilo, it is rather easy to state such idiocy. You would not be responsible, if she kills another bypasser because the mood strikes her and she noticed she can go very far with the guard. And you would be the first one outraged that the guard did not exclude a known murderer from the society, as soon as there would be a victim. So better shut up, before your hypocrisy becomes to obvious.
If a person already proved, that not violent means have no effect on his/her behaviour, we won´t give him/her hundreds of other chances to proof it again. If we would do so, we would not only fail in our duty, but would have to read comments from "honest and righteous" people on the town wall, that we are all corrupt and have been bought, in order to spare this special person her punishment.
If you were so honest and rightous, all of you would apologize, for insulting the honour of a man, that attacked a madwomen, who endangers you. But do not fear, we will not be very disapointed, if you do not, in order not to loose face in public, by admitting, you were wrong.
~Hagen von Rabenfeld~
~Commander of the town guard~