Page 1 of 1

fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Wed Jun 13, 2018 7:07 pm
by GolfLima
Ist das so gewollt und normal:
in den letzten 3 Monaten gab es 29 Obsidiane & 1 Saphir in Galmair

is this normal:
in the last 3 month my char got 29 obsidians and only 1 saphir

:?: :?: :?:

Re: fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Wed Jun 13, 2018 7:19 pm
by Jupiter
Diesen Monat gab es auch zwei Chars, die 0 Obsidiane und dafür 10 Saphire bekamen. Gab auch welche, die 5:5 bekommen haben. Hattest also vielleicht nur Pech. Irgendwann können wir mal wieder die Daten genau analysieren, um die Verteilung zu prüfen.

This month, there were also two chars getting 0 obsidians and 10 sapphiers. Also some got 5:5. So maybe you were just unlucky. Sometime, we can check the data once again to take a closer look at the distribution.

Re: fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Wed Jun 13, 2018 7:32 pm
by Dantagon Marescot
I have brought this up before after a massive drop that netted Dan 150+ Topaz and maybe 5 Amethysts. Very often I seem to get topaz and no amethysts. When this was last brought up it was pointed out that the overall distribution within town is 50:50 and it should be an encouragement to interact with others in town and trade with them. To me it seems a bit extreme and even a 70:30 distribution on a character would be preferred.

Re: fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Thu Jun 14, 2018 8:55 am
by GolfLima
OK,

kam mir nur etwas komisch vor, aber wenn es auch das andere Extrem gab scheint es normal zu sein. (( wenn auch m.E. nicht unbedingt wünschenswert ))

seems to be normal than

:arrow: :arrow: :arrow: kann geschlossen werden // can be closed

Re: fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Thu Jun 14, 2018 10:37 am
by Katharina Brightrim
I like the current system of different distributions since it actually encourages the exchange between chars who got different gems.

Re: fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Sat Jun 16, 2018 5:46 am
by Estralis Seborian
The system's name is "random" :-).

Re: fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2018 1:04 am
by JacobB
hm - I would call it 'bug' ;-)

Re: fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Sat Jun 23, 2018 5:05 pm
by Banduk
JacobB wrote:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 1:04 am
hm - I would call it 'bug' ;-)
I'd really like to know what is in fact the bug you claim?

Over all player of a realm and all time the distribution of magic gems is 1:1. That means the total number of latent magic obsidian is equal to the total number of latent magic sapphire. (same for the ruby=emerald and amethyst=topaz).

Even if you take any other action into consideration (treasure hunting, gathering ...) the number of is equal if we talk about long term and large numbers. So random will work for a MMORPG like Illa is pretending to be but not for a ORPG a lot of player take the game for.

Where's here the bug?

Re: fast nur Obsidiane für Steuern // nearly only obsidians as reward for taxes

Posted: Sun Jun 24, 2018 7:52 pm
by GolfLima
This is no bug - last month i got only saphires!!

it is only a bit confusing if you get one month ONLY obsidians and another month ONLY saphires